Old Navy Recalls Stuffed Toys; Button Eyes Can Detach and Pose a Choking Hazard to Young Children
Recall at a glance
- Recall number
- 09-134 (CPSC)
- Recall date
- February 19, 2009
- Brand
- Old Navy
- Category
- Toys and games
- Products
- Stuffed Animal and Creature Toys
- Hazard
- Choking and ingestion hazard
- Hazard type
- Choking and ingestion
- Units
- About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada
- Made in
- China
- Last updated by CPSC
- May 23, 2014
What was recalled
The stuffed animal and creature toys are made out of cotton and have plastic button eyes. They come in a variety of styles, such as a rabbit, penguin and reindeer. The recalled toys and style numbers are listed below: Type of Stuffed Toy Style Number Brown Plaid Creature (Stubby Stuberson) 612756 Pink Striped Dove 600571 Gray Dog 600572 Hot Pink Creature (Lucy Toothy) 612800 White Dog (Dr. Poopsie) 612738 Brown Penguin 612672 Light Pink Rabbit 612671 Brown Reindeer 612728 Dark Pink Rabbit (Honey O'Bunny) 612806 The style number is located on a white label sewn into the side seam of the toy.
Is my product affected?
Compare your product with the details below, including model numbers where listed.
- Stuffed Animal and Creature Toys · About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada units
Photos from the recall notice
Where it was sold
Companies named in the notice: Old Navy stores and on the Web at www.oldnavy.com from July 2008 through February 2009 for between $6 and $10.; Old Navy LLC, of San Francisco, Calif..
Consumer contact
For additional information, contact Old Navy toll-free at (866) 580-9930 between 9 a.m. and 9 p.m. ET Monday through Friday, or between 12 p.m. and 7 p.m. ET on Saturday, visit the firm's Web site at www.oldnavy.com, or e-mail the firm at custserv@oldnavy.com
Recall history and context
Old Navy appears in 4 CPSC recalls on record. See all Old Navy recalls.
Since 2019 CPSC has recorded 156 recalls in the toys and games category, 71 recalls of them in the past 12 months.
Frequently asked questions
What was recalled?
Stuffed Animal and Creature Toys (About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada units). The stuffed animal and creature toys are made out of cotton and have plastic button eyes.
Why was it recalled?
CPSC lists the reason as: Choking and ingestion hazard.
What should I do if I own one?
Consumers should immediately take the recalled stuffed toy away from young children and return it to any Old Navy store for a full refund. If purchased online, contact Old Navy for instructions on returning the toy for a full refund. Consumers who return the toy before July 1, 2009 will also receive a $5 coupon toward a future Old Navy purchase.
More recalls from Old Navy
- Old Navy Recalls Toddler Girl Aqua Socks
July 12, 2012 · Old Navy · Baby and nurseryThe slip-on shoes have pull-on tabs on both the front and back of the foot opening of the shoe. These Aqua Socks were sold in pink and purple in Toddler sizes 5-11. The…
- Old Navy Recalls Boys' Jackets; Drawstring at Waist Poses Entrapment Hazard
December 3, 2007 · Old Navy · Clothing and accessoriesThe performance fleece-lined shell jackets are hooded, zip in the front, and have a drawstring at the waist. The jackets were sold in black or blue in multiple…
- CPSC, Old Navy Announce Recall of Children's Zippered Outerwear
June 8, 2004 · Old Navy · Other consumer productsThis recall involves children's outerwear garments with a clear, oval-shaped zipper pull. The garments were sold in sizes 6 months to 4T. Style numbers are printed on a…
Similar recalls in toys and games
- BAMAMON Recalls LED Projecting Finger Light Toys
October 22, 2026 · BAMAMON · Toys and gamesThis recall involves Bamamon LED Projecting Finger Light toys which contain three button cells batteries. The finger lights come in 32 pieces in a box in red, orange…
- GBYMIUY Recalls Magnetic Stick Figure Toy Sets
October 1, 2026 · GBYMIUY · Toys and gamesThis recall involves GBYMIUY stick figure toy sets. The magnetic toys were sold in packs of 30 multi-colored transparent and opaque human-shaped figures. Each figure…
- LLK Trading Recalls Mochi Malrang Mystery Dumpling Toys
October 1, 2026 · LLK Trading · Toys and gamesThis recall involves Mochi Malrang Mystery Dumpling Toys. The mystery dumpling toys are a translucent red color, containing glitter and water beads. The toys have a…
- ABC Trading Recalls Squishy Toys
October 1, 2026 · ABC Trading · Toys and gamesThis recall involves squishy dumpling and crazy squib ball toys. The squishy dumplings, model 3655, come in multiple translucent colors, containing glitter and water…
- ABC Trading Recalls Light-Up Children’s Toys
September 24, 2026 · ABC Trading · Toys and gamesThese recalled products are packaged in a large clear plastic bag. A white label on the clear plastic bag has, in black font, one of the following identifiers: 6502 (for…
- Colerinsec Recalls Jerify Magnetic Stick Figure Toy Sets
September 17, 2026 · Colerinsec · Toys and gamesThis recall involves Jerify Magnetic Humanoid Toys 30 PCS. The 30-piece magnetic toys come in three units of brown, white, green, peach, yellow, pink, blue, orange…
Source: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission recall data, shown as published and last updated by CPSC on May 23, 2014. Details can change; the official notice is the authority. If your product may be recalled, stop and read the notice before deciding what to do. Terms and disclaimer.